Jakarta, Indonesia Sentinel — Indonesia records the highest number of methanol poisoning cases globally, with 329 incidents annually, according to Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders). This figure places Indonesia at the top of the list, followed by India (125 cases), Russia (117), Pakistan (38), and Bangladesh (34), as reported by ABC Indonesia on Sunday, December 8, 2024.
Cultural and Regulatory Challenges
Despite religious norms discouraging alcohol consumption in much of Indonesia, certain communities incorporate alcohol into their cultural traditions. However, methanol poisoning in the country is often linked to adulterated alcoholic beverages, known locally as oplosan, which include spiked drinks and traditional liquors like arak.
Dr. Ady Wirawan, a public health expert from Udayana University, highlights the lack of production standards for local alcohol, which often results in the accidental production of methanol instead of ethanol.
“Weak regulations and minimal oversight of illegal alcohol production and distribution perpetuate this practice,” he explained.
The high cost of legal alcohol in Indonesia drives consumers to cheaper, illicit alternatives, despite the severe health risks involved. Many consumers are unaware of the dangers posed by homemade alcoholic beverages, further exacerbating the problem.
The Stigma of Alcohol Consumption
A pervasive social stigma surrounding alcohol consumption worsens the methanol crisis. Victims of poisoning often avoid seeking medical help due to shame or fear of judgment. ”
Ideally, we would treat these patients immediately, but they hide their condition because they are embarrassed,” Dr. Ady noted.
Ironically, one of the most effective early treatments for methanol poisoning is ethanol, a safe form of alcohol. According to Dr. David Ranson, a forensic medicine professor at Monash University, administering ethanol slows the body’s processing of methanol, preventing its breakdown into toxic chemicals like formaldehyde and formic acid. These substances damage cells and disrupt energy production, leading to severe complications or death.
Psychological Toll
The psychological impact of methanol poisoning is equally devastating. Dr. Elvine Gunawan, a psychiatrist with Mental Hub Indonesia, recounted the story of a patient who survived a poisoning incident that claimed four lives. The survivor, blinded by the poisoning, was also subjected to social ostracism and internalized guilt.
“They believe they deserved the blindness or even death alongside their friends,” Dr. Elvine shared, emphasizing the long-term mental health struggles faced by survivors. Such cases highlight the urgent need for both medical and psychological interventions.
Indonesia Named World Most Generous Country for 2024
Medical and Ethical Considerations
While treatments such as fomepizole and dialysis exist, their availability in Indonesia is limited due to cost and infrastructure challenges. In 2018, Indonesia’s Council of Ulama permitted the use of ethanol for saving lives in cases of methanol poisoning. However, its implementation often depends on individual doctors’ ethical considerations.
“This is not for sinful use; rather, it is to save lives, so it is allowed. But again, it depends on the ethical values of the doctor,” Dr. Ady remarked.
Moving Forward
Efforts to address Indonesia’s methanol crisis require strengthened regulation of alcohol production, increased public awareness of the risks, and improved accessibility to effective treatments. Combating stigma around alcohol consumption is equally vital to ensure victims seek timely medical assistance.
(Becky)
